Book of Mormon was the only show I’m seeing on Broadway this trip that I’d already seen. (I’d seen the touring production when it came to Toronto last spring.) I loved it then and I loved it here. And I’ll definitely see the Broadway Across Canada production when it comes to Edmonton next season. The dancing was even better than I’d remembered and more of the songs had interesting choreography, even Hello! right at the start. I was amused that the little bits of product placement in the Salt Lake City backdrop still included Tim Hortons (and I wondered whether this coffee shop chain is particularly successful in a city where lots of people don’t drink coffee). Elder Kevin Price was Nic Rouleau, Elder Arnold Cunningham was Ben Platt, and Nabulungi was Syesha Mercado. None of them were from the original cast but the show Playbill said that they’d all played or understudied in the roles elsewhere first. All of them were good singers, actors, and dancers, and Nic Rouleau had a really great smile too.
I also figured something out which was probably obvious to everyone else who had seen the show before. See, after I saw it in Toronto I looked at the headshots in my program book and realised the cast didn’t include any white women – but I remembered the scene with the missionaries’ mothers and fathers seeing them off at the airport, and the Mormon-history narrative with pioneer couples. I couldn’t figure out whether some of the Black women in the cast had done those parts with wigs and I had just seen them as white, or what. Well, this time I paid more attention – and the white men in the chorus of missionaries also play all the white women.
Again, I loved the staging and choreography of Spooky Mormon Hell Dream, for being terrifying, original, and pointedly ridiculous, all at the same time. The flamboyant / ironic choreography of the missionaries’ chorus numbers was also one of my favourite parts of the show. Elder Cunningham’s names for Nabulungi definitely didn’t include Nanaimo Bar this time around, so that confirms my hypothesis from Toronto that the actor must have the freedom to improvise that a bit and change from show to show.
At the show I attended, there weren’t any real missionaries outside. But as in Toronto at one of the Mirvish theatres, there were lots of souvenirs for sale, and lots of patrons who knew the show well. And I’ll have to check my program from that production to be sure, but I think that possibly a few of the actors from the touring production that I saw might be in the Broadway cast now. Otherwise, it’s unusual for me (with most of my theatregoing limited to Edmonton) to be seeing a good show without recognising any of the performers. Perhaps that will change here too, since I hope this is not my last visit to Broadway.